Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

German Museums Almost as Frustrated as Families Seeking Restitution

November 20, 2013 by Marion Maneker

moritzburg-xLarge

The New York Times puts a face and story the abstract issue of Germany’s failure to address the legal issues surrounding the art works seized by the Nazis. They spoke to Wolfgang Buche, a curator who is frustrated by the situation:

“The legal situation is relatively obvious and clear,” said Mr. Büche, who oversees the collection at the Moritzburg Foundation in Halle. “With art taken from Jewish collectors, there are sometimes legal or at least moral circumstances under which they can seek to have their works restituted. We can only seek to buy them back.” […] Mr. Büche, the curator, would like his pictures back, too. Yet, in his three decades at the Moritzburg museum, he has been able to celebrate the return of just 16 prewar items, a tenth of a collection that once ranked among the most impressive in the country.

Some of the museum’s prewar works now hang in the Museum of Modern Art in New York or at Harvard University after having been traded on the open market like many so-called degenerate works once confiscated by the Nazis.

Only occasionally do those works travel back to Halle on loan. Such special exhibitions are the biggest draw to the museum, which, despite a renovation in 2008, struggles to attract 60,000 to 70,000 visitors a year.
“We always try to buy back our works, when they turn up, but as a state-funded museum, we can’t compete against big bidders,” Mr. Büche said.

Enduring Nazi Law Impedes Recovery of Art (NYTimes)

Schjeldahl: If the Munich Hoard Were in a Museum, It’d Be in Storage

November 18, 2013 by Marion Maneker

Peter Schjeldahl pretty much gets to the heart of the matter on the Munich Hoard: Where did Focus magazine get that $1bn valuation?

Every journalistic account of Gurlitt’s inventory reflexively bandies the word “masterpieces” or, for variety, “masterworks” and cites a speculated market value of a billion dollars. From what I’ve seen of the photographic evidence, phooey. Aside from a lovely Matisse, there appear to be only minor works, mostly by middling German Expressionist and Neue Sachlichkeit painters, of a grade that museums might want but would usually keep in storage. In 2011, Gurlitt sold probably the jewel of his hoard, “The Lion Tamer,” by Max Beckmann, for a bit more than a million dollars—which he had to share with heirs of its Jewish original owner. […] Gurlitt has been quoted as lamenting that people see “banknotes” in his cherished works on paper. Check. If it weren’t for a contact high from the lately intoxicated art market, and the Nazi angle, this whole affair would be back-page news.

Cornelius Gurlitt, the Art Hermit (The New Yorker)

Gurlitt Speaks: The Spiegel Interview

November 18, 2013 by Marion Maneker

File photo of name plate on the house of art collector Cornelius Gurlitt in Salzburg

Spiegel’s original story from which most are quoting is now available in english and worth reading for the portrait it portrays of Cornelius Gurlitt. The story reminds us that the German laws governing the art, its ownership and the statute of limitations on when claims can be made against it is the real issue in the case:

He doesn’t understand what people want from him. He says the public prosecutor’s office has the pictures now, so people should go there if they want to see the works or find out something about them. He knows a lot about their origins, he says, but he prefers to keep that to himself — like a love affair that needs to be guarded. “And there is nothing I have loved more in my life than my pictures.” […]

Gurlitt has to answer so many questions for which he has no answers. “I never had anything to do with acquiring the pictures, only with saving them,” he says. He helped his father back in Dresden when they saved the works of art from the Russians. People should be thankful to him, he says. “My father knew the Russians were getting closer and closer.”

His father quickly organized a vehicle from the carpool in Dresden, he recalls, and father and son loaded the artwork into the car. His father then brought everything to a farmer near Dresden, and later to a castle in southern Germany. He says that his father knew people everywhere in Germany.

“People only see banknotes between these papers with paint — unfortunately,” he says. 

SPIEGEL Interview With Cornelius Gurlitt About Munich Art Find (SPIEGEL ONLINE)

Gurlitt’s “Precious” Pictures

November 17, 2013 by Marion Maneker

Cornelius Gurlitt

The story of the Gurlitt family, their deceptions and obvious awareness that their art trove was no legitimately theirs seems to have turned their son into a real life Gollum:

Speaking to Der Spiegel last week, during a trip to an unidentified German town to see a doctor for a heart condition, Mr. Gurlitt said he had not watched television since 1963 and had never gone online, but did talk to his pictures. He kept his favorites, a collection of works on paper, in a small suitcase that he would unpack each evening to admire.

Until the raid in February 2012, Mr. Gurlitt had guarded his privacy zealously, refusing to open his door even to meter readers from the gas company. He rarely spoke to or even acknowledged his neighbors. He had no friends whom anyone ever saw. […] The collection was so valuable and, perhaps, its provenance so tainted by the family’s association with the Nazis, that the desire to keep it secure compelled Mr. Gurlitt to live a strange, Gollum-like existence behind permanently drawn blinds, obscuring not only the works but also the man himself. […] “People only see banknotes between these papers with paint, unfortunately,” he said. […]

Konrad O. Bernheimer, a prominent Munich art dealer, said he had never come across Mr. Gurlitt despite decades in the business. “The saddest part of this whole story is this man’s life,” he said. “He was locked up in the dark with all these wonderful paintings. He is a man in the shadows, a ghost who never came out.”

For Son of a Nazi-Era Dealer, a Private Life Amid a Tainted Trove of Art – NYTimes.com.

The Munich Hoard: One Man’s Story

November 12, 2013 by Marion Maneker

Max-Liebermann-Two-Riders-on-the-Beach-Oil-Canvas-Art-P15393854

The Wall Street Journal puts flesh and a personal story upon some of the claimants to works discovered in the Munich Hoard. David Toren received a call from Lothar Fremy, a Berlin restitution lawyer who has worked on previous objects from the David Friedmann collection:

Mr. Toren said he was one of the only living relatives of David Friedmann, who records say once owned the painting, and plans to file a claim for it. “Two Riders on the Beach” was one of a handful of works revealed by the German authorities last week at a news conference about the Munich collection.

“It’s mine. Who else should get it?” Mr. Toren told The Wall Street Journal on Monday in a phone interview from his home on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. “It’s the only picture I remember from my uncle.”

Mr. Friedmann, a well-to-do Jewish art collector, owned about 10 paintings that were targeted for seizure by the Nazis, including another Liebermann piece, “The Basket Weaver,” and paintings by Camille Pissarro and Henri Rousseau, according to a letter from the Gestapo that Mr. Toren said he has. […]

He can still picture Mr. Friedmann’s home—”the whole house was like a museum,” he said—and described a trove of paintings, porcelain, pottery, Persian rugs and antique furniture.

Mr. Toren learned to ride horses on his great uncle’s 10,000 acres of land about an hour from Breslau in the province of Silesia. Mr. Friedmann made his fortune as a landowner, leasing acreage for farmers to grow sugar beets. The property included a sugar factory, a distillery and a hunting lodge, Mr. Toren said.

Mr. Friedmann, who died peacefully in his sleep in the early 1940s, had a daughter who committed suicide after being briefly imprisoned by the Nazis, Mr. Toren said.

American Scion of German Family to File Nazi Art Claim  (WSJ.com)

Next Page »
LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...