Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

The Other Shoe in That Haring Case

February 5, 2018 by Marion Maneker

Bloomberg has delved into the filings on the Shagalov case to unearth the other issue in the case. Sotheby’s resold the Haring tarp for $4.4m to the third-party guarantor after going back to the other bidders. Shagalov complained that the work was being sold below market value. He made that claim based upon a letter of intent from a Spanish buyer:

Two months after Sotheby’s sued, Shagalov says he found a potential buyer for the Haring work on his own — Marco Mercanti, founder of the Madrid-based art firm Oblyon. Mercanti conditionally agreed to pay $5 million through a financing agreement with JPMorgan Chase & Co., according to court papers. Shagalov says that offer — memorialized in an October letter filed in court — is evidence that Sotheby’s failed to get the best possible price on the resale.

Unfortunately, the letter offered seems to have been back-dated to before Sotheby’s demands for payment from Shagalov. That has raised a a separate set of issues about the lawyers. But on the point of the reasonable value of the work, Mercanti seems to have evaporated as a serious buyer once the legal issues surrounding the work were revealed to him and his firm.

There’s a deeper issue here that Bloomberg points out that Shagalov’s lawyer, Mathew Hoffman, has been remarkably frank about. As the art market continues through nearly a decade of steadily rising values, there are more and more buyers out there who engaged in highly leveraged art-trading.

Shagalov’s business, based in Great Neck, New York, is “always the same, which is borrow money, buy art, sell art, pay loans back,” his attorney, Hoffman, said at a Jan. 9 hearing, according to a transcript. “This was an ordinary course of business transaction for him.”

One has to wonder how many art buyers out there are equally leveraged.

Sotheby’s Battles N.Y. Art Dealer Over Keith Haring Winning Bid – (Bloomberg)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Sotheby’s Sues Shagalov for Non-Payment on Haring SaleSotheby’s Sues Shagalov for Non-Payment on Haring Sale
  • Is Tepid Hong Kong Sale of Warhol’s Mao a Sign of the Chinese Market’s Lack of Interest?Is Tepid Hong Kong Sale of Warhol’s Mao a Sign of the Chinese Market’s Lack of Interest?
  • Zhang Xiaogang and Key Chinese Contemporary Artists from Storied Johnson Chang Collection Come to AuctionZhang Xiaogang and Key Chinese Contemporary Artists from Storied Johnson Chang Collection Come to Auction
  • Bacon, Picasso, Lichtenstein Top 2020 Global Modern & Contemporary Auctions: AnalysisBacon, Picasso, Lichtenstein Top 2020 Global Modern & Contemporary Auctions: Analysis
  • Van Rysselberghe, Klee, Magritte Lead June 2020 Paris Impressionist and Modern Sales: AnalysisVan Rysselberghe, Klee, Magritte Lead June 2020 Paris Impressionist and Modern Sales: Analysis
  • As Coronavirus Escalates, Sotheby’s Relocates Modern and Contemporary Hong Kong Sales to New YorkAs Coronavirus Escalates, Sotheby’s Relocates Modern and Contemporary Hong Kong Sales to New York

Filed Under: General Tagged With: Keith Haring, Sotheby's

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...