Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

Is It Really This Easy to Manipulate an Artist’s Market?

December 13, 2017 by Marion Maneker

Something about the Leonardo sale, surely its price tag, has provoked the oddest behavior among art market editors. Before the New York Times editor who handles art market coverage commissioned their reporter to write an inside account of the search fo the Leonardo buyer, the arts editor at the Financial Times penned a long piece about the Leonardo sale:

“This, some people felt, was just too mad. It was perhaps the first inkling that a market that is undeniably exciting and exhilarating might be on the edge of becoming seriously troubling.”

Here the Leonardo sale is also used as an opportunity to promote occasional FT contributor Georgina Adams’s new book, The Dark Side of the Boom. Like the heavy breathing about the art market becoming seriously troubling, the rest of the FT piece offers several scenarios of bad behavior ranging to from money-laundering to market manipulation but with little in the way of real-world examples.

Here’s the FT suggesting it is much easier to manipulate an artist’s market than most dealers or collectors would believe:

“Adam gives a word-of-mouth example, which works as follows . . .  You buy 10 works by a young artist for, say, $10,000. After a year or so of planting bits of hype here and there, you place one work in an auction. You and a co-conspirator then bid the work up and up, say to $100,000. Once the hammer has fallen at that level — because the chief way of determining prices in art is simply by previous achieved prices — you can (slowly, no rushing) sell off the other nine works at similarly inflated rates. At an enormous profit.”

The conjecture here is followed by the comment, “Again, not actually illegal.” But that surely isn’t true. Bidding on property you own is not legal. In the rare cases like divorce or the heirs to an estate bidding on works, the erstwhile or tangential owners have to disclose that they are bidding.

It is also not legal for bidders to coordinate their bids. That’s a bidding ring. Before the auction houses became the locus of all fears in the art market, there were real problems with dealers getting together and dividing up the lots in sales to reduce the competition and prices. That’s also blatantly illegal.

No one is suggesting buyers and sellers don’t try to put their thumb on the scale. But that doesn’t mean the act isn’t illegal. And if the FT has knowledge of such behavior, it might do the public a favor by publishing it.

$400m for a Leonardo da Vinci? Has the Art Wold Gone Mad? (Financial Times)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Blue-Chip Focus: Irving PennBlue-Chip Focus: Irving Penn
  • $19 M. Francis Bacon Portrait of Sole Heir Heads to Sotheby’s London Auction$19 M. Francis Bacon Portrait of Sole Heir Heads to Sotheby’s London Auction
  • Tate Adds £14m in WorksTate Adds £14m in Works
  • No Nostalgia for BaryshnikovNo Nostalgia for Baryshnikov
  • Lazarides Sells Banksys at BonhamsLazarides Sells Banksys at Bonhams
  • Bonhams Asia Week ResultsBonhams Asia Week Results

Filed Under: General

About Marion Maneker

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

Top Posts

  • After Pandemic’s Rapid Change, Sotheby’s Has 8 Predictions for 2021
  • For 2020, Phillips Brought in Total of $760.4 million, Down 16 Percent from 2019; Asia Sales Up 24 Percent
  • Keith Haring’s 1989 Retrospect Comes to Sotheby’s London Prints Sale
  • A Season of Resilience: Fall 2020 Hong Kong Auction Analysis
  • Tony Podesta's Secret Art Buying
  • A Season of Improvisation: Fall 2020 New York Modern and Contemporary Art Auction Analysis
  • Soulages First Owned by Senegalese Poet-Politician Léopold Sédar Senghor Sells in France
  • Four of Picasso's Women Valued at $28m Come to Christie's from Rose-Walters Collection
  • Norman Rockwell's Not Gay. But Is He a Great Artist?
  • Christie's Announces $70m Picasso Self Portrait
  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor