Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • Contact Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • AMMpro

Sotheby’s (Not Surprisingly) Wins Its Caravaggio Case

January 16, 2015 by Marion Maneker

Caravaggio, Card SharpsThe Telegraph has the verdict from the London court tasked with determining if Sotheby’s was negligent in doubting an example of The Card Sharps was by Caravaggio. The issue came before the court because Denis Mahon later declared the work to be an original thus making its value orders of magnitude above what the original consignor had sold it for:

A judge found that the auction house was “entitled to rely on the connoisseurship and expertise of their specialists”, who were ” highly qualified and examined the painting thoroughly”.

“They reasonably came to the view on the basis of what they saw that the quality of the painting was not sufficiently high to indicate that it might be by Caravaggio,” she added.

After the ruling, a Sotheby’s spokesman said: “Sotheby’s is delighted that today’s ruling dismisses all claims brought against the company and confirms that Sotheby’s expertise is of the highest standards.

“After a four-week trial in which five witnesses for Sotheby’s and three independent experts gave testimony, the judge concluded that Sotheby’s was not negligent and that the Sotheby’s Old Master Painting specialists who assessed the work were ‘highly qualified,’ examined the painting ‘thoroughly,’ and reasonably came to the view that the quality of the painting was ‘not sufficiently high’ to merit further investigation.”

Caravaggio in court: Sotheby’s wins case after ‘£10m’ painting sold for £42,000  (Telegraph)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • London Old Masters Evaporates by 41% in 2 YearsLondon Old Masters Evaporates by 41% in 2 Years
  • Art Litigation Amuck: The Caravaggio CaseArt Litigation Amuck: The Caravaggio Case
  • Sotheby’s Declares Another Old Master FakeSotheby’s Declares Another Old Master Fake
  • Scenes from the Contemporary Art Sales in LondonScenes from the Contemporary Art Sales in London
  • Is the Price of Connoisseurship Capriciousness?Is the Price of Connoisseurship Capriciousness?
  • False Alarm: Wildenstein Trial Delayed on Constitutional Ruling that Won’t Come Until MayFalse Alarm: Wildenstein Trial Delayed on Constitutional Ruling that Won’t Come Until May
  • Print
  • Tweet

Filed Under: General

Advertise on Art Market Monitor with Nectar Ads

Top Posts

  • Phillips London Contemporary Has Richter, Kippenberger and Lichtenstein
  • Agnes Gund & Oprah Winfrey Lead Auction of Women Artists at Sotheby's to Benefit Miss Porter's School
  • Sotheby's Celebrates Bauhaus's Centenary with 25 Works in Imp-Mod Sales
  • Frank Stella Sells Some Work—His Own and Others—at Christie's
  • Christie's Announces $70m Picasso Self Portrait
  • Four of Picasso's Women Valued at $28m Come to Christie's from Rose-Walters Collection
  • Frieze LA Sales Report
  • David Hockney's $20m Pacific Coast Highway & Santa Monica
  • Ludwig Deutsch Leads Bonhams £2.59m 19th C Sale
  • Newsletter


  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • Art Loans
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Advertise on Art Market Monitor