Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

I’ll Trade You Three Urinals for that Rubens

November 19, 2014 by Marion Maneker

Robert Gober, Three Urinals (3.5-4.5m) 2.5m USD
Robert Gober, Three Urinals (3.5-4.5m) 2.5m USD

It’s a shame to see such a brilliant, thoughtful and valuable art historian like Bendor Grosvenor succumb to splenetic envy in the Financial Times. It’s worse that the editors of the Financial Times have egged him on to write this screed about Robert Gober and mock his work because it’s easy to snigger at someone paying a lot of money for three urinals. Eeeew!

Ostensibly, Grosvenor is upset at the way the market assigns value. (“[A] Gober urinal will buy you a fine Rubens.”) Gober is a fascinating and important artist. He’s hardly the market-driven fraud Grosvenor makes him out to be. And Gober’s gain need not be Rubens’s loss. This is especially poignant because Bendor Grosvenor is one of the best equipped persons to help revive interest in Old Masters and make them relevant, a project that seems worthy and needful.

We’ll have to wait for the series of columns that excites our interest and improves our appreciation of Rubens. In the meantime, you can skip Grosvenor’s mis-understanding of market economics and the repetition of silly conspiracy theories about guarantees and auction bidding:

we have collectively lost the ability to assess art for ourselves and on its own merits. Instead, we follow such indicators as fashion, price, and, in this case, hype. You may say it was ever thus. But the result today, when allied with an ever wealthier elite for whom buying contemporary art has become a form of conspicuous consumption, is an unprecedented art boom. Can it last?

Normally, speculative bubbles end when an underlying financial reality hits home. The subprime boom ended when homeowners stopped making repayments. But in the art world there are few such constraints. The only requirement is that works keep edging up in value.

And if they do not? Well do not worry, for the market has developed ways to help make sure the numbers go up – or at least appear to.

Contemporary art is judged by its price tag not by aesthetics   (FT.com)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Neha Kirpal’s Path from Business Plan on Airsickness Bag to Eighth Annual India Art FairNeha Kirpal’s Path from Business Plan on Airsickness Bag to Eighth Annual India Art Fair
  • Artelligence Podcast: London Contemporary Recap with Scott Reyburn of NYTimesArtelligence Podcast: London Contemporary Recap with Scott Reyburn of NYTimes
  • The Poverty and Patience of Willem de KooningThe Poverty and Patience of Willem de Kooning
  • Edelman's GuaranteeEdelman's Guarantee
  • Bendor Grosvenor Scores a Rubens AttributionBendor Grosvenor Scores a Rubens Attribution
  • From Zero to Hero: Galleries, Museums and Auction Houses Collaborate to Bring Movement to Center StageFrom Zero to Hero: Galleries, Museums and Auction Houses Collaborate to Bring Movement to Center Stage

Filed Under: General

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...