Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

You Say You Want Regulation in the Art Market . . .

July 8, 2014 by Marion Maneker

In response to a flurry of stories about fakes on the Indian art market, Girish Shahane responds with this Quartz piece pointing out the ironies of expecting government regulation to work for the art market. Shahane is specifically concerned with Indian art but his comments could easily be applied anywhere in the world:

It is curious how Indians, who never tire of holding forth about the incompetence and corruption of government, seem always to conclude that the solution to any intractable problem lies in the setting up of a government committee. Those in the trade should be careful what they wish for, because, should the government actually create a  authentication panel, it will almost certainly be a disaster. For example, we can expect demands for original works to be shipped to the Capital for inspection in a process that will take months, since committees constituted of authorities living in different regions of India can’t be expected to meet every week. At the end of it, there is no guarantee that forgeries will always be spotted, or that authentic works will always be certified as such, since these things often come down to a matter of opinion. And opinions differ, even among impartial experts.

In actual fact, Indian art requires less, not more, regulation. Expertise and transparency have been strangled by the Antiquities Act, which makes the owning and selling of antiquities difficult, their export illegal, and restricts trade in the work of a number of modern artists labeled national treasures, Rabindranath Tagore and Nandalal Bose among them. While there is no silver bullet solution for the problem of forgeries, partial fixes emerge as a natural consequence of trade. Buyers develop relationships of trust with dealers. Certain individuals receive widespread recognition for their connoisseurship, and become established authenticators. Foundations publish catalogues raisonnés, which are comprehensive listings of all known works by artists. This last has never happened in India, partly because of the huge expense involved, partly because many collectors don’t wish to reveal the extent of their holdings, and partly because family members of dead artists, who often become the authenticators of choice, want to make the most of that privilege.

As fakes unnerve India’s art market, the trade is pushing for an antiquated solution (Quartz)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Sotheby’s Presents Its 2015 H1 Results, Up 5%Sotheby’s Presents Its 2015 H1 Results, Up 5%
  • The Smell of Money in the Desert HeatThe Smell of Money in the Desert Heat
  • Ullens Turn Their CollectionUllens Turn Their Collection
  • Mark Moore Gallery @ PulseMark Moore Gallery @ Pulse
  • Why Galleries Look to Rediscover ArtistsWhy Galleries Look to Rediscover Artists
  • Chinese Aren’t the Only Ones Who Refuse to Pay Chinese Aren’t the Only Ones Who Refuse to Pay

Filed Under: Fraud, Theft & Restitution

About Marion Maneker

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

Top Posts

  • Keith Haring’s 1989 Retrospect Comes to Sotheby’s London Prints Sale
  • British Modernists Draw Deep Bidding in Christie's $42 M. London Sales
  • Four of Picasso's Women Valued at $28m Come to Christie's from Rose-Walters Collection
  • Norman Rockwell's Not Gay. But Is He a Great Artist?
  • How to Chant Like an Auctioneer
  • Tony Podesta's Secret Art Buying
  • $10 M. Picasso Portrait Unseen for Decades to Sell at Bonhams
  • Collection of Texas Heiress Anne Marion Expected to Fetch $150 M. at Sotheby’s
  • Vienna Secession Painting, Long Thought to Be Lost, Sets a Record at Auction
  • Tracey Emin Neon Lights Up Sotheby's 'Contemporary Showcase' Pop-Up
  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor