Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

When the Law Bows to the Art Market

August 6, 2012 by Marion Maneker

One judge in New York has all three cases coming out of the Knoedler mess. The New York Times uses this as an occasion to explore the relationship between art, the law and authenticity. The thing is, courts have limited powers to establish authenticity. The article tries to show this by recapping the famous Duveen case involving a supposed Leonardo:

Legal thinking on questions of authenticity has evolved since. Judges now recognize that while their word is law in the courtroom, in the art world their verdicts can be overturned by a higher authority: the market. “A decision by a court in the United States that a work is authentic may or may not have any value,” said the lawyer Peter R. Stern. “It’s totally up to the market.”

It’s when we get to the market that the chasm grows:

A 2009 opinion also involving a Calder stated the divide between the court and the market more bluntly. At issue were a couple of stage sets that Calder had designed but did not live to see completed. When the owner, Joel Thome, tried to get the Calder Foundation to authenticate the works so he could sell them, it refused. Mr. Thome sued and lost. The Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court explained its rejection of Mr. Thome’s appeal by referring to “Rio Nero.” The fate of that artwork, Justice David B. Saxe wrote in his opinion, illustrates “the inability of our legal system to provide a definitive determination of authenticity such as is sought by plaintiff.” Having the court declare the sets to be authentic is meaningless, he told Mr. Thome, “because his inability to sell the sets is a function of the marketplace.”

Ruling on Artistic Authenticity: The Market vs. the Law (New York Times)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Deaccessioning Police Branch OutDeaccessioning Police Branch Out
  • Rare of the Rare Chinese Ceramic Draws Crowds in BeijingRare of the Rare Chinese Ceramic Draws Crowds in Beijing
  • NYTimes Magazine Lays an Egg on Art StorageNYTimes Magazine Lays an Egg on Art Storage
  • Christie’s NY Imp-Mod & Jan Krugier = $293.6mChristie’s NY Imp-Mod & Jan Krugier = $293.6m
  • Frieze New York 2019 Sales ReportFrieze New York 2019 Sales Report
  • Saltz on Brooklyn FeastSaltz on Brooklyn Feast

Filed Under: Fraud, Theft & Restitution

About Marion Maneker

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

Top Posts

  • Keith Haring’s 1989 Retrospect Comes to Sotheby’s London Prints Sale
  • Roy Lichtenstein’s Top Ten Auction Prices
  • Tony Podesta's Secret Art Buying
  • Four of Picasso's Women Valued at $28m Come to Christie's from Rose-Walters Collection
  • David Hockney's $20m Pacific Coast Highway & Santa Monica
  • Norman Rockwell's Not Gay. But Is He a Great Artist?
  • How to Chant Like an Auctioneer
  • Behind the Fireworks at Sotheby's $363 M. Sale, More than a 'Game Show'
  • Basquiat's Last Girlfriend
  • Phillips Includes $2.5m Norman Rockwell Painting in November Evening Sale
  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor