Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

The Strange Case of the Caravaggio Discovery

July 10, 2012 by Marion Maneker

The Telegraph reports that the ebook claiming to have re-attributed a cache of works owned by the City of Milan as works by Caravaggio has been withdrawn from Amazon (though it remains for sale on lulu.com.)

The claim itself was outlandish but some of the reaction is ante-diluvian in its starched skepticism that any valid claim could be made outside of the academic establishment:

The withdrawal of the book raised questions about why the historians’ claims, which garnered worldwide media attention, had not been peer-reviewed. […] A panel of heritage experts from Castello Sforzesco, the castle where the archive of sketches and drawings is kept, would scrutinise “with rigour the ideas advanced by the authors of the e-book,” he said. […]

Maria Teresa Fiorio, the former director of the castle’s collection, said last week that she was “perplexed” by the claims made in the book. “A serious scholar doesn’t produce an e-book – they would publish their findings in the appropriate journals. Everyone who has studied the collection has asked themselves – is it possible that some were drawn by Caravaggio? No one has drawn that conclusion.”

The authors claim their work’s many images are essential to making their case. Of course, the publication and publicity surrounding it has generated exactly the sort of “peer review” one would want if your case was convincing.

Amazon Withdraws Controversial Caravaggio Book (Telegraph)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • London Old Masters = £107mLondon Old Masters = £107m
  • Albada Jelgersma Collection ‘A Seminal Moment’ for Old Master Market, Says Christie’sAlbada Jelgersma Collection ‘A Seminal Moment’ for Old Master Market, Says Christie’s
  • Action in the Old Masters Market in Unlikely Places Action in the Old Masters Market in Unlikely Places 
  • Seemingly Strong Old Master Sales Offer Mixed InterpretationsSeemingly Strong Old Master Sales Offer Mixed Interpretations
  • The ‘Aesthetic of the Unfinished’ Pushes Rubens to Top of OM Paintings and Drawings Week in NYCThe ‘Aesthetic of the Unfinished’ Pushes Rubens to Top of OM Paintings and Drawings Week in NYC
  • Who Owns Authenticity in the Hals Case?Who Owns Authenticity in the Hals Case?

Filed Under: Critics Tagged With: Old Masters

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...