Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

Doubting Leonardo

April 13, 2010 by Marion Maneker

You’ll remember the supposed Leonardo “discovered” a few years ago and the fingerprint analysis that gave ballast to the theory. The vellum was also carbon dated to the potential period. The Telegraph‘s Richard Dorment dismantles the idea in detail:

Against all this, Kemp’s opponents point out that of the 4,000 or so surviving drawings by Leonardo, not a single one is on vellum. But vellum is a material a copyist might well use – because sizeable sheets of monastic vellum of the correct age are easy to come by, whereas blank sheets of paper made during Leonardo’s lifetime are not.

Nor does the observation that a left-handed artist drew the portrait convince the sceptics. According to Pietro C Marani, Italy’s most distinguished Leonardo scholar, who oversaw the restoration of The Last Supper : “The fact that one is looking at a drawing by a left-handed artist does not carry any weight: there exist copies of drawings by Leonardo made by imitators which present this particular characteristic – by, Francesco Melzi, for example, as Kenneth Clark and others have already written.” Likewise, a copyist could easily arrive at the sitter’s costume by studying any Milanese 15th-century portrait. Even the drawing’s obvious antiquity has drawn fire from one museum director, who asked not to be named. He believes the drawing is not even 19th century, and thinks it is “a screaming 20th-century fake”, made up out of a “compilation of obviously Leonardesque elements that is not even close to Leonardo himself”. For this well-known connoisseur of Italian painting and sculpture, the damage and repairs are suspicious, for, although apparent to the naked eye, they are not so extensive that they make the picture unappealing or unsaleable – as it would be, for example, if the repairs disfigured the face.

La Bella Principessa: a £1000m Leonardo, or a copy? (Telegraph)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Daily Mail Says Regional Rivalry Drove Leonardo BiddingDaily Mail Says Regional Rivalry Drove Leonardo Bidding
  • Yes, It’s a Leonardo. Stop Calling It a Fake.Yes, It’s a Leonardo. Stop Calling It a Fake.
  • Is the Leonardo Record a Self-Fulfilling Prophecy for Salvator Mundi’s Fame?Is the Leonardo Record a Self-Fulfilling Prophecy for Salvator Mundi’s Fame?
  • Brooke Lampley on Leonardo Buyer’s ToleranceBrooke Lampley on Leonardo Buyer’s Tolerance
  • Watch Salvator Mundi Become the Most Expensive Work of Art SoldWatch Salvator Mundi Become the Most Expensive Work of Art Sold
  • This Is What the Buyer of the Leonardo Is Paying ForThis Is What the Buyer of the Leonardo Is Paying For

Filed Under: Artists Tagged With: Leonardo

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...