Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

ArtPrice v. Christie's

February 9, 2010 by Marion Maneker

Artprice, the French art information service, released a long and convoluted press release today with a headline–“Artprice: Christie’s Makes Another Vain Attempt to Take Control of Artprice at a Lower Price…”–that implies Christie’s is trying to takeover the firm but content that accuses Christie’s of  . . . , well, we’re not entirely clear what the charge against Christie’s is:

With complete transparency, Artprice, represented by its founder Thierry Ehrmann, hereby wishes to inform its 18,000 shareholders and the markets that Christie’s Manson and Woods Ltd, Christie’s France SAS and Christie’s France SNC have launched a civil claim concerning our use of their sales catalogues and corporate identities (which they consider a “brand”) and what they call acts of “parasitism” in using the announcements and results of their public sales.

What follows is a lengthy disquisition on Artprice’s use of Christie’s catalogue material and their claim that their own work is protected under a sui generis copyright:

Unlike the auction houses, which just offer visitors to their websites the possibility to download their catalogues, Artprice dissects these catalogues in order to analyse the data within a specific industrial process and then restructures the analysed data into several variable fields constituting Artprice’s original databases which are protected by sui generis copyright protection laws.

Christie’s responds:

From the launch of their website service, Artprice reproduced in their entirety more than 2300 of Christie’s catalogues on its website without permission. Due to the seriousness of this copyright and trademark infringement, in 2008, Christie’s commenced legal action against Artprice in France, where it is based. Christie’s has not been alone in bringing proceedings against Artprice in the French courts. The French courts have already concluded that Artprice improperly used Christie’s trademarks, and Christie’s is confident of a further favourable decision from the French courts with respect to Christie’s copyrights.

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Christie’s Can’t Wait, New York Sales Move to October with $25 M. Cézanne AnnouncementChristie’s Can’t Wait, New York Sales Move to October with $25 M. Cézanne Announcement
  • Bacon, Picasso, Lichtenstein Top 2020 Global Modern & Contemporary Auctions: AnalysisBacon, Picasso, Lichtenstein Top 2020 Global Modern & Contemporary Auctions: Analysis
  • Van Rysselberghe, Klee, Magritte Lead June 2020 Paris Impressionist and Modern Sales: AnalysisVan Rysselberghe, Klee, Magritte Lead June 2020 Paris Impressionist and Modern Sales: Analysis
  • Christie’s Has Richard Feigen Collection in MayChristie’s Has Richard Feigen Collection in May
  • Christie’s Sells £11.4m Leyden Drawing to Benefit Rugby SchoolChristie’s Sells £11.4m Leyden Drawing to Benefit Rugby School
  • Christie’s Ebsworth Scores with $317m Evening SaleChristie’s Ebsworth Scores with $317m Evening Sale

Filed Under: General Tagged With: Artprice, Christie's

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor