Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • Contact Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • AMMpro

Chinese Motives

November 24, 2009 by Marion Maneker

Peter Neville-Hadley in the  Wall Street Journal delves deeper into the controversy stirred up by the Chinese over items looted from the sacked Summer palace:

Strident demands for the unconditional surrender of looted works of art are frequently made by Chinese officials. In the Chinese narrative, the destruction and looting of the Summer Palace were simply wanton acts of foreign imperialist greed and oppression, and are repeatedly presented as such in schools and the media. The aim is to show foreigners as united in attempting to invade and oppress China, and the Communist Party as the only bulwark behind which the Chinese people can effectively come together.

In fact, the British and French forces were present in China to obtain ratification of a treaty concluded with the Manchu overlords of China two years earlier, and under arrangements agreed with a Manchu prince, they sent an advance party under flag of truce to arrange details of the signing at a village just east of Beijing. The members of the party were taken prisoner and tortured; 18 died.

The looting and destruction of the Summer Palace was in revenge for this kidnapping and murder. British plenipotentiary Lord Elgin chose to strike directly at the Manchu Qing dynasty, much despised by the Chinese themselves, destroying palaces and art collections, rather than causing further loss of Chinese life. But it is rare for any narrative of 1860 other than the government’s own to appear in China. In 2006 when philosophy Professor Yuan Weishi suggested in China Youth Daily’s Freezing Point supplement that the destruction was largely the result of Manchu stupidity, he was disciplined, the publication was suspended for “rectification,” and its editor, fired.

China Goes Treasuring Hunting (Wall Street Journal)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Sotheby’s Hires New York Chinese WoA HeadSotheby’s Hires New York Chinese WoA Head
  • Chinese Communist Party Wants Culture Industry to GrowChinese Communist Party Wants Culture Industry to Grow
  • The Rabbit and Rat Can Be SoldThe Rabbit and Rat Can Be Sold
  • I'll Show You Mine, If . . .I'll Show You Mine, If . . .
  • The Chinese Were No Strangers to Picasso but They Didn’t Drive Up the Price of the Late WorksThe Chinese Were No Strangers to Picasso but They Didn’t Drive Up the Price of the Late Works
  • Peter Paul Biro Loses Libel SuitPeter Paul Biro Loses Libel Suit
  • Print
  • Tweet

Filed Under: General

Advertise on Art Market Monitor with Nectar Ads

Top Posts

  • Bonhams Brings Second Generation of Modern Vietnamese Art in Hong Kong
  • David Hockney's $20m Pacific Coast Highway & Santa Monica
  • Four of Picasso's Women Valued at $28m Come to Christie's from Rose-Walters Collection
  • Artelligence Podcast: Pamela Joyner on Collecting Abstract Art by African-American Artists
  • Why I Am Leaving Gagosian
  • About Us/ Contact
  • Peploe Leads Scottish Colourists at Lyon & Turnbull
  • Norman Rockwell's Not Gay. But Is He a Great Artist?
  • Newsletter
  • Man Ray's Noire et Blanche (€1-1.5m) Offered at Christie's France in November


  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • Art Loans
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Advertise on Art Market Monitor