Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

Stealing from American Indians

November 3, 2009 by Marion Maneker

In art, they say that talent borrows and genius steals. Either way, American Indian artisans are getting pushed out of their own market, according to the Wall Street Journal. The numbers of imported knockoffs of American Indian designs are simply staggering and heartbreaking, since much of the imported work is intentionally passed off as the real thing:

The authentic Indian-made earrings are on the right.
The authentic Indian-made earrings are on the right.

The Indian Arts and Crafts Association, a trade group, estimates that nationally, as much as 75% of the roughly $1 billion of jewelry, pottery, rugs and other merchandise sold every year as authentic is not. In the jewelry business, as many as 90% of pieces held out as examples of Native American craftsmanship are fake, according to the New Mexico attorney general’s consumer-protection division, which is trying to police the trade along with federal authorities.

But it is extremely hard to tell the genuine goods from the faux artifacts, artists and experts say.

Some of the imported jewelry is exquisite, studded with real gems and painstakingly crafted — only, it is made by Chinese or Thai or Filipino workers abroad, not by Native American artisans. Other pieces are mass-produced with polished bits of plastic that look uncannily like real jewels.

See the Journal’s article for a list of tips on how to spot authentic Indian works of art.

Cheap Jewelry Imports Vex Artisans in Southwest (Wall Street Journal)

    More from Art Market Monitor

    • Artelligence for June 11, 2018Artelligence for June 11, 2018
    • Christie’s Keeps At Outsider Art MarketChristie’s Keeps At Outsider Art Market
    • What Do Steven Cohen’s Art Sales Mean?What Do Steven Cohen’s Art Sales Mean?
    • Portrait of Inauguration Poet Amanda Gorman Gifted to HarvardPortrait of Inauguration Poet Amanda Gorman Gifted to Harvard
    • Cindy Sherman, More or LessCindy Sherman, More or Less
    • Prints Under PressurePrints Under Pressure

    Filed Under: Fraud, Theft & Restitution

    About Marion Maneker

    LiveArt

    Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

    • About Us/ Contact
    • Podcast
    • AMMpro
    • Newsletter
    • FAQ

    twitterfacebooksoundcloud
    Privacy Policy
    Terms & Conditions
    California Privacy Rights
    Do Not Sell My Personal Information
    Advertise on Art Market Monitor
     

    Loading Comments...