Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • AMMpro
  • AMM Fantasy Collecting Game
  • Podcast
  • Contact Us

Aftermath of an Afr-Am Collection's Loss

August 8, 2009 by Marion Maneker

The New York Times picks up on the Peggy Cafritz fire in Washington, DC that destroyed a distinctive collection of African-American Art and tells how Ms. Cafritz is dealing with the aftermath:

Detail from Kerry James Marshall“I’m hoping I can be strong enough not to be hit by that ton of bricks, not to become dysfunctionally sad,” said Ms. Cafritz, 62, as she sat on a couch in her temporary home this week. “Right now my emotions are submerged, like under water.”

The destruction of the collection is being mourned in museums and galleries too, particularly among connoisseurs of contemporary African-American and African art. Thelma Golden, director of the Studio Museum in Harlem, praising Ms. Cafritz’s “unique eye and incredibly refined aesthetic,” called it “a great loss.” Jack Shainman, the New York gallery owner, lamented the destruction of “a singular vision.” […]

Some of it was politically provocative. In addition to abstract paintings, nudes and more formally inventive pieces — an inflatable baby that looked as if it were breathing, stereo speakers bedecked in sequins — the collection included a slave ship fashioned from wood and African fabrics, by Yinka Shonibare; a painting of George W. Bush in a cowboy hat, firing pistols in a rain forest (“Bush Gardens,” it was called), by Thales Pereira; a photolithograph of a naked black woman titled “Not Manet’s Type,” by Carrie Mae Weems; and an ink-jet image of a black basketball player dangling from a noose, entitled “Hang Time Circa 1923,” by Mr. Thomas.

It was a collection that rarely left viewers unmoved, according to several artists and museum officials who saw it, though it certainly didn’t appeal to everyone, said Michael Chisolm, a New York art historian who completed an appraisal of the works last year for insurance purposes.

Traditionalists “would probably be appalled and horrified by Peggy’s collection,” said Mr. Chisolm, who, like Ms. Cafritz, declined to divulge the collection’s value. “But it was the kind of thing that a museum could take in its entirety and fill galleries with. It was really, in a sense, a monument to the place that artists of color, particular of African descent, have taken in the art world.” It also reflected the life and sensibilities of Ms. Cafritz, a wealthy African-American woman who is a prominent patron of the arts and a political fund-raiser, one who has long considered herself a bridge between the haves and have-nots in a city still polarized by race and class. Born in Mobile, Ala., she was for many years the wife of Conrad Cafritz, a white real estate developer from a prominent family. (They divorced in 1998.)

The Times adds a second story investigating the fire’s devastation, particularly the trouble firefighters had finding sufficient water pressure in several hydrants nearby to fight the blaze:

But fire officials added, in a preliminary report on the fire, “While low water flow unquestionably impacted the time needed to put out the fire, it is not clear that higher water pressure would have saved the house.” In the last two years Washington has had a spate of fires that have leveled major landmarks, including the historic Eastern Market, the Georgetown Library and a large condominium in the city’s popular Adams Morgan neighborhood, raising questions about the preparedness of the city’s fire department and the local water authority.

A Collection’s Ashes, a Heritage’s Seeds (New York Times)

Art Collection Burns, and Officials Offer Reasons (New York Times)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Elizabeth Catlett, Hughie Lee Smith Lead Swann African-American Sale in OctoberElizabeth Catlett, Hughie Lee Smith Lead Swann African-American Sale in October
  • Swann African-American Art = $4.5mSwann African-American Art = $4.5m
  • Beauford Delaney, Jacob Lawrence, Norman Lewis, Charles White and Elizabeth Catlett Lead Swann African-American Art SaleBeauford Delaney, Jacob Lawrence, Norman Lewis, Charles White and Elizabeth Catlett Lead Swann African-American Art Sale
  • Swann African American = $2.7mSwann African American = $2.7m
  • Barkley Hendricks Big Week at Sotheby’sBarkley Hendricks Big Week at Sotheby’s
  • A New Plateau for the African American Art MarketA New Plateau for the African American Art Market

Filed Under: Collectors Tagged With: African American

About Marion Maneker

LiveArt

Want to get Art Market Monitor‘s posts sent to you in our email? Sign up below by clicking on the Subscribe button.

  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
California Privacy Rights
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Advertise on Art Market Monitor
 

Loading Comments...