Art Market Monitor

Global Coverage ~ Unique Analysis

  • Contact Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Fantasy Collecting Game
  • AMMpro

What the Elgin Marbles Mean to India

July 10, 2009 by Marion Maneker

One of the arguments against the return of the Elgin Marbles is the precedent it would set and the danger that precedent would pose to the great museums of London, New York and Paris. But here’s an interesting post from India’s Livemint.com where Mandipa Mandal makes a case that Indians have a stake in the return of the Acropolis frieze:

Indian art and culture critics seem to hardly have taken notice, though — and yet they should. For the sake of the peacock throne and the Kohinoor that has become a ‘Crown Jewel’ in quite the wrong crown. They sit in British hands, like the stigma of imperialism. […]

The argument of “world heritage” for “global consumption” falls flat to my ears. Why not argue the same about Nazi relics? Because of course to the victor belong the spoils, and the right to write history. […] To those who argue that it sets a poor precedent which could empty prized collections: I agree—that is the point, precisely. The precedent for emptying out poorer collections has long been set, and the need is for perspective, preferably a global and non-parochial, anti-imperial one, to be restored. No longer is Greece, or for that matter India, a beleaguered nation incapable of protecting its heritage and waiting for divine (White missionary) intervention for their salvation.

Why India Should Root for the Return of the Elgin Marbles (Livemint.com)

More from Art Market Monitor

  • Dealer’s Sister Arrested in Globe-Spanning Antiquities CaseDealer’s Sister Arrested in Globe-Spanning Antiquities Case
  • You Say You Want Regulation in the Art Market . . . You Say You Want Regulation in the Art Market . . .
  • Accomplice in Selling Stolen Indian Artifacts and Faking Ownership Confesses in CourtAccomplice in Selling Stolen Indian Artifacts and Faking Ownership Confesses in Court
  • Singapore Museum Keeps Watchful Eye on Subhash Kapoor Court CaseSingapore Museum Keeps Watchful Eye on Subhash Kapoor Court Case
  • Acropolis Museum Receives More Artifacts from AbroadAcropolis Museum Receives More Artifacts from Abroad
  • France, The Capital of Art Theft, Part 2France, The Capital of Art Theft, Part 2
  • Print
  • Tweet

Filed Under: Fraud, Theft & Restitution

Advertise on Art Market Monitor with Nectar Ads

Top Posts

  • Sotheby's Announces $150m+ Modigliani
  • What's Going On In the Condo Market?
  • Robert Frank Is Worried About the Art Market
  • Christie's Has Agnes Martin, Ellsworth Kelly from Brad Grey Estate
  • David Norman Talks Picasso with the FT
  • Art Cologne Sales Report
  • Login
  • Christie's $30m Rothko from 1954 for May
  • Scholars Get Ready for Modigliani-mania at the Tate
  • Artcurial Has Lejard Collection of Légers & More


  • About Us/ Contact
  • Podcast
  • AMMpro
  • Newsletter
  • Art Loans
  • FAQ

twitterfacebooksoundcloud
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Advertise on Art Market Monitor