Art Market Monitor

Denis Dutton’s Op-Ed in the New York Times condemning conceptual art to the ash heap of history because it does not contain skill and craftsmanship drew many approving comments across the Internet. Some thoughtful folks wrote in to the newspaper to poke a few holes in his argument:

Oriane Stender:

Denis Dutton begins by condemning an entire genre on the basis of its noisiest, worst examples. (If I don’t like the work of Thomas Kinkade, do I have to dismiss landscapes, still lifes and representational paintings of houses?) From there, he segues into an appreciation of skill and finely honed craft. I, too, am a great admirer of skill, craft and beauty, but this does not preclude my getting something — something different perhaps — from the best conceptual art. And often the most powerful artwork is that which balances visceral sensory impact with intellectual content. I love seeing the hand of the maker, but the dichotomy of the hand and the head adds another level of complexity to the experience.

Gary Mailman:

[W]hile it may be true, as Mr. Dutton claims, that artistic technique and craftsmanship help make it possible to “find beauty,” the technique and craftsmanship necessary to reproduce virtually exactly the work of, say, a Van Gogh sunflower will not create for the forgery anywhere near the “value” of the original, notwithstanding that few could distinguish between the two paintings were they hanging side by side. Owning the forgery is simply not the same as owning the original, and prestige, not “beauty,” accounts for much of the difference.

William Cole:

[O]ver the long run, the market values artists who are original for how they paint, rather than artists who are original for what they paint.

Love the Concept. But Is It Art? (NY Times)

Also of Interest:

• Is Craftsmanship Beauty?
  The New York Times had an interesting op-ed yesterday that argues what lasts, long after the concept of a piece...
  
• Savaging Lisa Yuskavage
  Jerry Saltz lays into Lisa Yuskavage who has a show up at Zwirner: The same bogus arguments come up every...
  
• Painting to See His Name Everywhere
  Sixeart is a Spanish griffiti artist turned painter who spoke with the Wall Street Journal recently. He’s also refreshingly honest...
  
• Hirst at Home
  Sarah Thornton went to visit Damien Hirst in his studio to see the famous conceptual artist as he begins a...
  
• The Hot Roerich
  With apologies for missing this yesterday, the New York Post covers the arrest in the recovery of the second Roerich...