Insurance Broker Says Pollock Painting is Real

Wow. Didn’t see this coming, did you? The bizarre story of the Pebble Beach art theft has now devolved into finger-pointing accusations with Benjamin Amadio calling the Monterey Sherrif’s department corrupt or incompetent and the Sherrif doubting the existence of the art work. Amadio now claims $72,000 worth of insurance on the artwork, as the Boston Globe tells us:

The Monterey County sheriff’s commander, Mike Richards, said Dr. Ralph Hennaugh, formerly of Harvard University, and art dealer Benjamin Amadio may be involved in a “criminal enterprise,’’ and that authorities were investigating “other scenarios.’’ He said Amadio and Hennaugh [...] could face charges of filing a false police report. He said fraud charges also could be considered if the evidence eventually points in that direction.

“This whole thing stinks,’’ Richards said. [...] “There has been no response to requests for photographs, receipts, identification of sellers, nothing.’’

“We have $72,000 worth of insurance,’’ Amadio said. “If we wanted money, we would’ve sold the art. It’s worth millions.’

The San Francisco Chronicle quotes the pair’s insurance broker who says he saw the documentation and the Pollock painting:

Amadio said documentation of the paintings’ authenticity, including what he described as an original bill of sale from Pollock, had been stolen in the heist – but not before being seen by his insurance broker, David St. John.

In an interview Tuesday, St. John said he had seen the paintings and documents establishing their lines of ownership. He said he had been in the process of trying to insure the more valuable works, but was stymied by his clients’ landlord, who he said wouldn’t allow the installation of a security system. Amadio and Kennaugh “don’t need the money,” St. John said. “They want the art back. It’s really unfair what’s happening to these guys.”

St. John’s ex-wife is Vicki St. John, who is listed as the attorney for Alternative Asset Investments, Amadio’s company, on the firm’s Web site.

Ex-Harvard Professor, Art Dealer Called Suspects in Theft Case (Boston Globe)

‘Art Theft’ Smells Fishy, Investigators Say (SF Chronicle)

Also of Interest:

• Massive Art Theft in Pebble Beach
  Here’s a story that contradicts much of what the experts tell us about art thefts which is that they are...
  
• The Pebble Beach Story
  The Pebble Beach art heist is turning into one of the most embellished stories ever to hit the media. Tawana...
  
• Pebble Beach Theft Gets Weirder
  If you thought the Pebble Beach art theft valued at $27 million was a little fishy, there’s more coming: a...
  
• A Little More on PB Theft
  The Monterey County Sheriff’s department is not very happy with Benjamin Amadio. They’ve taken the highly unusual step of speculating...
  
• In Defense of Duchamp
  Sebastian Smee is the Boston Globe‘s art critic. Here he mounts a defense of Marcel Duchamp that takes into account...